On May
27-28, 1905, the decisive battle of the
Russo-Japanese war – the Battle of Tsushima – took
place in the Korean straits. What do Russians know
about these hundred year old historical events?On
May 27-28, 1905, the decisive battle of the
Russo-Japanese war – the Battle of Tsushima – took
place in the Korean straits. What do Russians know
about these hundred year old historical events?
Asked what
associations “Tsushima” evoked, 24% of respondents
recalled the defeat of the Russian Baltic Fleet, as
well as other episodes of the 1904-05 war. Another
13% made general comments about Japan. Almost
two-thirds of those surveyed (62%) gave no reply to
the question.Asked what associations “Tsushima”
evoked, 24% of respondents recalled the defeat of
the Russian Baltic Fleet, as well as other episodes
of the 1904-05 war. Another 13% made general
comments about Japan. Almost two-thirds of those
surveyed (62%) gave no reply to the question.
At the same
time the majority of Russians said they “know” or
“had heard something” about the Russo-Japanese war
(34% and 39%, respectively), and 19% said they never
heard of it before. However, only 28% managed to
remember particular events from the war. Respondents
mentioned the siege of Port Arthur (8%), the last
fight of the cruiser Varyag (8%), and the Battle of
Tsushima (9%). Around 7% gave general assessments of
the war: At the same time the majority of Russians
said they “know” or “had heard something” about the
Russo-Japanese war (34% and 39%, respectively), and
19% said they never heard of it before. However,
only 28% managed to remember particular events from
the war. Respondents mentioned the siege of Port
Arthur (8%), the last fight of the cruiser Varyag
(8%), and the Battle of Tsushima (9%). Around 7%
gave general assessments of the war:
"It was a
great naval war”; “We lost because of poor military
equipment compared to the Japanese”; “It was a
disgraceful defeat”; “Russian soldiers died for God
knows what”; “Our fleet fought to the utmost and
would not surrender". (answer to open-ended
question)."It was a great naval war”; “We lost
because of poor military equipment compared to the
Japanese”; “It was a disgraceful defeat”; “Russian
soldiers died for God knows what”; “Our fleet fought
to the utmost and would not surrender". (answer
to open-ended question).
Perceptions
and knowledge of historical events form in people’s
minds mainly due to their value aspect. Especially
important is the mechanism of glorification, which
can impart a particular sense to historical facts
and thus strengthen their perception in people’s
minds. It is indicative that only 12% of respondents
called the Battle of Tsushima the most decisive
episode of the war, although many people (24%) have
a definite idea of this battle, notwithstanding the
fact that its anniversary was mentioned widely in
the media recently. The sinking of the cruiser
Varyag, an event that little influenced the course
of war, but which bears a more distinct notional
value, comes in first – 20%. The heroic defense of
Port Arthur has a similar value, and is next at 19%.
The bloody battles of Mukden and Liaoyang were not
mentioned once: obviously these names, also
mentioned in school history classes, conveyed
nothing to respondents.Perceptions and knowledge of
historical events form in people’s minds mainly due
to their value aspect. Especially important is the
mechanism of glorification, which can impart a
particular sense to historical facts and thus
strengthen their perception in people’s minds. It is
indicative that only 12% of respondents called the
Battle of Tsushima the most decisive episode of the
war, although many people (24%) have a definite idea
of this battle, notwithstanding the fact that its
anniversary was mentioned widely in the media
recently. The sinking of the cruiser Varyag, an
event that little influenced the course of war, but
which bears a more distinct notional value, comes in
first – 20%. The heroic defense of Port Arthur has a
similar value, and is next at 19%. The bloody
battles of Mukden and Liaoyang were not mentioned
once: obviously these names, also mentioned in
school history classes, conveyed nothing to
respondents.
The most
unexpected results, however, came from another
question: how did the war end for Russia – in
victory or defeat? Only one-third of respondents
(35%) said Russia lost the war; 27% think Russia
won, while 38% found it difficult to answer. This is
where a significant difference comes up between
those who “know” and those who “have heard
something” about the Russo-Japanese war. Among the
former, 65% say the war was lost, while 24% hold the
opposite opinion. The latter speak more often about
a Russian victory - 37%, against 30% who believe
that our nation won.The most unexpected results,
however, came from another question: how did the war
end for Russia – in victory or defeat? Only
one-third of respondents (35%) said Russia lost the
war; 27% think Russia won, while 38% found it
difficult to answer. This is where a significant
difference comes up between those who “know” and
those who “have heard something” about the
Russo-Japanese war. Among the former, 65% say the
war was lost, while 24% hold the opposite opinion.
The latter speak more often about a Russian victory
- 37%, against 30% who believe that our nation won. |